In February of 1957, when police officers received a tip about a random cardboard box lying on the side of the road, they didn’t know that the discovery would become a mystery that would shake their town and the entire country for decades to come. The body of a young boy would be found stuffed inside the box and his identity would remain a mystery for over 65 years. This is the story of the boy in the box, and the murder of Joseph Augustus Zarelli.